Home » ExchangeEveryDay » Limits of Direct Instruction



ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues


<< Previous Issue | View Past Issues | | Next Issue >> ExchangeEveryDay
Limits of Direct Instruction
May 8, 2015
Love recognizes no barriers. It jumps hurdles, leaps fences, penetrates walls to arrive at its destination full of hope.
-Maya Angelou

Exchange Emerging Leader Claire Vallotton shared this great Slate article, "Why Preschool Shouldn't Be Like School," by Alison Gopnik. In the introduction Gopnik asks... "Shouldn't very young children be allowed to explore, inquire, play, and discover? Perhaps direct instruction can help children learn specific facts and skills, but what about curiosity and creativity — abilities that are even more important for learning in the long run?... While learning from a teacher may help children get to a specific answer more quickly, it also makes them less likely to discover new information about a problem and to create a new and unexpected solution."

One of the experiments Gopnik shared was from her lab at UC-Berkeley in which researchers introduced 4-year-old children to a new toy and demonstrated a series of three actions.  Some sequences caused the toy to play music, but not all. Only the sequences that ended with the same two actions made the music play. One of the researchers, Daphne, ran through the same nine sequences with all children, but with one group she acted as if she were clueless about the toy. ("Wow, look at this toy. I wonder how it works?") With the other 4-year-olds, Daphne acted like a teacher. ("Here's how the toy works.")

"When she acted clueless, many of the children figured out the most intelligent way of getting the toy to play music (performing just the two key actions, something that Daphne had not demonstrated). But when Daphne acted like a teacher, the children imitated her exactly, rather than discovering the more intelligent and more novel two-action solution."





The Philosophical Baby

by Alison Gopnik
One of the key experts in the film, "The Beginning of Life"

In the last decade there has been a revolution in our understanding of the minds of infants and young children. We used to believe that babies were irrational, and that their thinking and experience were limited. Now Alison Gopnik — a leading psychologist and philosopher, as well as a mother — explains the cutting-edge scientific and psychological research that has revealed that babies learn more, create more, care more, and experience more than we could ever have imagined.

Learn More and Purchase

ExchangeEveryDay

Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

What is ExchangeEveryDay?

ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

Free resources to help Head Start staff meet goals.

Save

Kaplan – 15% Off Plus Free Shipping!
Softerware, Make Managing Your Childcare Center Easier.


Comments (3)

Displaying All 3 Comments
Kathy Modigliani · May 12, 2015
Family Child Care Project
Arlington, MA, United States


Alison Gopnik keeps identifying fundamental issues. Promoting children's figuring out the answers vs. direct instruction leads to better outcomes in early childhood programs.

I suspect that this approach would also work better in elementary school, and it should be mingled into high school, higher ed., and adult ed.

How can we keep this approach while also embracing the accountably movement that is here to stay?

Francis Wardle · May 08, 2015
CSBC
Denver, CO, United States


Finally! This concept is so critical, especially at a time when we are moving dangerously too far in the direction of direct instruction and "intentional teaching". The only quibble I have with the author is the word allow; we should be encouraging exploration, play, and discovery. The number one early childhood standard should be, "to discover, explore, play, and inquire"! But what are we going to do about this?

Beth Engelhardt · May 08, 2015
University of Dayton
Dayton, Ohio, United States


I am three quarters of the way through another great book on this topic. The Great Disconnect in Early Childhood Education, What we know vs. What we do by Michael Gramling. His book is a brilliant piece of work laying out how we got in this mess and what to do about it.



Post a Comment

Have an account? to submit your comment.


required

Your e-mail address will not be visible to other website visitors.
required
required
required

Check the box below, to help verify that you are not a bot. Doing so helps prevent automated programs from abusing this form.



Disclaimer: Exchange reserves the right to remove any comments at its discretion or reprint posted comments in other Exchange materials.