This was the title of the January 5, 2011 entry by Sue Shellenbarger in the Wall Street Journal Blogs. Long-time advocate for child care, Shellenbarger observed...
"Most talk of child-care costs focuses on how much families have to pay - a tab that for many parents rivals the cost of the mortgage or groceries. Since 2000, child-care costs have been rising twice as fast as families' median income and the average cost that parents paid for full-time care for a 4-year-old child in a center ranged from more than $4,050 in Mississippi to more than $13,150 a year in Massachusetts.
"But a new survey reported in today's Wall Street Journal underscores another harsh truth about child care - that it is also a costly and demanding profession for workers to enter. In a study comparing 200 occupations based on income, working environment, stress, physical demands, and the job outlook, child-care workers rank in the lowly 186th spot - barely higher than taxi drivers, roofers, and roustabouts...
"The economics of child care have long been out of whack. Amid an absence of the government subsidies offered by some European nations, few U.S. parents can afford to pay the full cost of high-quality child care. This forces child-care centers to survive partly by cutting labor costs, driving trained, educated, skilled people to abandon the field... Yet numerous studies have shown that the core ingredient of high-quality child care is a child's relationship with his or her teacher, a factor that is linked to higher teacher training and education. Higher pay tends to draw better trained, better educated teachers...".
Shellenbarger closes her blog entry with...
"Readers, do you think child-care workers should be paid higher wages, or would it take too much of a hit out of your pocket? Would you ever want to be a child-care worker?"
The Beginnings Workshop Book Professionalism contains insightful articles on Being Teachers, Professionalism, Caregiver Health & Safety, Mentoring, Observing Children, Collaboration and Child Care in Unique Environments. This book can be ordered individually or as part of the discounted set of 9 Beginnings Workshop Books.
Sale ends May 19, 2015 at 11:59 pm PDT.
May not be combined with any other offer.
Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.
ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.
Comments (11)
Displaying 5 of 11 Comments [ View all ]Pre-K 4 Program
Birmingham, Al, United States
My biggest shock with working in a quality preschool program is how some preschool teachers deal with bullies. They tell the victim to go over there and hit the bully back. I've witnessed these types of interactions while out on the playground. The child will say, "Teacher! He hit me when I tried to climb up on the jungle gym! He didn't want me up there with him so he hit me!" The teacher will say, "He can't be doing that to you. You go over and hit him back. Then you'll be even." I've seen this and heard these types of interactions dozens of times in the last couple of years. It's terrible that some of the preschool teachers believe in revenge and settling scores with violence. No wonder some of the worst bullies in Kindergarten are children who attended a preschool.
Mansfield Children\'s Center
Mansfield, Texas, United States
The article is true, but missing a few "facts". It always seems that we the "owner/operators" of child care facilities are just raking in the money at the expense of our teachers and ultimately of our children. But if you've ever tried to maintain a high quality Center - you would know that the costs are prohibative! First of all you are considered pretty lowly human beings if you a a "for profit" business - everything automatically costs you MORE!! Insurance, taxes, and the cost of goods/gas/transportation equipment, maintenance & upkeep, licenses & permits, and then you have more and more strenuous regulation required with little or no thought to cost - all of which have to passed on to our clientele. Those of us who try to help out by allowing CCMS families at our Center's - suffer with very low reimbursment rates - far below what it actually costs to care for, nurture, feed and teach a child for 12 hours a day! And then you have the school districts going into direct competition with those they levy taxes on! They make it as hard as they can on us - giving us a 20 minute window of time to pick up children after school - in an enormous district - causing us to have to send out more buses or serve fewer children. They are able to charge less because they don't have transportation costs, are able to advertise their services at the schools (we are not!), etc. etc. etc. As an owner, I have never taken a salary - and poured every "extra" cent back into my school. My teachers are the best - personal income is not what keeps them doing what they do - it's something in their heart that only God can provide. No one would be happier than I if I could pay my teachers more - and do more for them. But until the "government" sees that we are worthy - and tie incentives instead of punishment to those of us who do superior work inspite of the negatives we have to deal with, I'm afraid the way of quality child care will continue to suffer - but as far as "lowly" child care wokers are concerned - they are also some of the best teachers of young children there are!
kelins kid kare
casa grande, az, United States
After 11 years, our's is still a "small child care group home", ie, under 10. We are comfortable with six 2 & 3 year old's. Our childrens parents are mainly self-pay, non DES. 60 hour plus weeks are normal. Filled with love, understanding and future directions for all these children. Yeah, financese are important. Yet, how can one ignor our kids love and the parents thanks? The children have learned, we have learned and God welling we will continue to make a difference in their future life's.
United States
I do my job because I love to help children. If I had to support myself alone there is no way I could do it.
So as parents climb the corporate ladder their tuition is actually an investment since no one has to stay home "to raise the kids." When they reach school age they are cared for virtually for free.
Sick or healthy the children are delivered to our door each day to be cherished and nurtured.
It's a lowly job, but honorable. The hand that rocks the cradle rules the world.
Sebastopol, California, United States
I would guess roofers make more....as do pet care and dog walkers make more than those who teach our youngest children, except that is for the very wealthy who hire whomever they wish.
Post a Comment