Shop by Topic
Shop by Product
ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues
<< Previous Issue
| View Past Issues | | Next Issue >> 
Child Care vs Elder Care Revisited
July 2, 2008
You will face many defeats in life, but never let yourself be defeated.
-Maya Angelou
-Maya Angelou
"I find it very troubling that this article is set to ignite a generational war. Instead of seeing it as an "us versus them", I think a better approach is to work towards universal health care and preventive services at all age levels. It also posits older adults as being a drain on the economy, when in fact, they provide a potentially huge economic boon to the economy.
"Older adults are continuing to work past what was considered 'retirement age' for the last generation — this puts a huge amount of extra dollars into the public pot via income taxes. Furthermore, this generation owns the majority of businesses in this country — they are the cornerstones of our economic vitality. Add into this the huge contribution of older adults in the civic arena via volunteerism. Who is picking up the slack and caring for grandchildren when parents either can't or won't parent effectively? Who do you think is going to spend time mentoring and tutoring our youngsters in the future? Who will be doing fundraising for a wide variety of causes, including those targeted to young children?
"I don't see it as a pie that is continually cut into smaller pieces. I think we need to rethink our national priorities and together make a bigger, better pie/social net for all of our vulnerable citizens."
View the story from June 20 and view all 13 responses.
The Exchange Job Opportunity service now lists director, teacher, and sales positions in New Zealand, California, Washington, Michigan, Connecticut, New Jersey, Wisconsin, Missouri, Ohio, North Carolina, Maryland, Colorado, Texas, Illinois, Oregon, Virginia, and Utah. Check them out if you are considering a change of scenery, or post your jobs if you are looking for new team members.
ExchangeEveryDay
Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.
What is ExchangeEveryDay?
ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.
Together, side by side... we can help your employees balance work and life!
CCLC offers quality and innovative employer-sponsored child care programs nationwide. We work with you help your employees balance work/life obligations, including: child care needs assessments, back up child care, on-site/near-site child care, national priority access programs. Learn more today!
CCLC offers quality and innovative employer-sponsored child care programs nationwide. We work with you help your employees balance work/life obligations, including: child care needs assessments, back up child care, on-site/near-site child care, national priority access programs. Learn more today!
Comments (8)
Displaying All 8 CommentsMt Kisco Day Care Center
Mt Kisco, NY, United States
How about thinking intergenerationally?
I work in a shared site intergenerational facility. We have 150 children (3 mos- 5th grade) and 50 older adults who attend each day. Children and elders come together throughout the day to build relationships through activities like music, art and storytelling. Children learn from elders and elders share the joy of their youth. It is very exciting to be part of this program.
Intergenerational sites are cost effective because they allow you to share resources. We call the program the JEWEL program. Joining Elders With Early Learners. It is truly a treasure! For more information visit MKDCC.org or learn more from Generations United and Donna Butz the Director of that program.
Social Services
Durand, Illinois, United States
I couldn’t agree more with what Susan Starrfield of Snohomish County Human Services in Everett, Washington said. Every generation has needs to be met by society and there is not one more important than another. Actually, older adults are key in contributing to the needs of the young. I don’t know what I would have done without the assistance of both my grandmother and father who provided awesome child care for my children while I attended to my job. They were dependable and wonderfully connected to meeting the needs of the children. We’re all in this together!
Sharon Wegler
Winnebago County, Illinois
United States
I am thrilled to see that Exchange chose to share Susan's comments. It was a shocking and disrespectful position to take on an issue that has many other solutions. Thank you Susan for the reminders about so many invaluable contributions being made by the generation addressed in the article and also how both generations need to remain important and considered when working toward solutions for a healthy America.
United States
A number of people have expressed concern about the excerpt from my book "Finding Our Way: The Future of American Early Care and Education", in which I flag the possibility that the elders making up the 'baby boom' generation may compete with young children for scarce public resources. Unfortunately Exchange Every Day did not include the full quote from my book. The piece they excerpted (without asking me) was followed by the following:
"Although the challenges posed by greater demand for early care and education and increased competition from elders for scarce public resources are great, the graying of America also represents a window of opportunity. Many of these seniors will have grandchildren, whose welfare will be of great concern to them. If addressed sensitively, these sentiments could be translated by early care and education advocates into a powerful voice for improvements in the ECE services available to young children."
I agree with all those who responded by saying that elders and children can both be supported with public resources, and that the oldest generation can be a wonderful resource to the youngest. However, this will require very intentional planning by all of us. In the absence of such intentionality I worry about the possible consequences of gnerational competition, especially given the fact that children don't vote.
United States
I was grateful that others had commented on this; it was very exclusionist and I think the best society is one in which we all view others as having something to contribute, rather than being in competition with each other or resenting others.
Nichols Hills UMN CDO
Oklahoma City, Okalahoma, United States
Amen!! Well said.
Tri-County Head Start
United States
Thank you, thank you, thank you....for posting a very positive response to a subject we found troubling.
It evidences your concern for the general readership.
I thoroughly enjoy reading your articles, and find the quote for the day often fits a particular situation
currently facing me.
Again, thank you.
Helen
cambridge, ma, United States
Thank you for revisiting this and sharing Susan's thoughts. She is articulate and right on target. We need to have this attitude toward all the problems facing the world.
This way of thinking will help us to tackle our current environmental, energy, war and population troubles. I thank you for publishing this and for the reminder about working together and seeing the big picture, not the small problems that are presented to use each and every day.
Post a Comment